- Quick guide to keeping your cool in reporting season
- Key reasons why Aussie investors are facing an interest rate dilemma
- Looking beyond the share price – a key lesson from CBL’s capitulation
- Rotation to large caps ‘uncomfortable’ but creating opportunities
- 30 years after 1987 – how stock market crashes can make you a better investor
- Avoiding the next Vocation: Five “watch outs” for selecting stocks
- Is the market expensive? Four reasons this is the wrong question to be asking
- What makes the table-topping Prime Value Cash Plus Fund tick?
- Stocks to watch in an uncertain market: CSL
- Two big takeouts for investors from 2016
- Five reasons why absolute return investing is less volatile than index investing
- Six keys to finding value in the market
- Brexit: Implications for investors
- Difficult start to 2016 for share market – opportunities exist for high conviction stock pickers
- Prime Value’s views on current market volatility
- Short-term cycles to continue into 2015
- Some stocks cope with volatility better than others
- Reporting Season Underlines Need For Strong Fundamentals
- In the world of finance, the most dangerous thing is the thing that never moves
- 2014 shaping as a stockpickers market
- Dark Clouds On The Horizon – Risk Or Opportunity?
- Three Chances at Getting it Right
- Keeping on top of the RORO markets
- Notes from China
- Spring Cleaning The Investment Pantry
- Does Corporate Memory Have A Role In Stockpicking?
- How Do You Harvest Your Returns?
- Why Avoiding the Herd is More Important than Ever
- Safe Bets In Turbulent Times
- History: First Multinational Renaissance Business
- How Bees Invest
Why Avoiding the Herd is More Important than Ever
Fiona Clark, 3 July 2012
Macquarie published an interesting piece of research this month, entitled “Australian Quant Action: A stock picker’s pickle”, which shows that the challenge for stock pickers is higher than ever – Tony Featherstone provides a good summary here.
The research found that ASX 200 stocks are now moving more closely together. Macquarie studied the correlation of each stock’s return in the S&P/ASX 200 index to every other stock’s return, using a year of weekly returns. Correlation measures how closely things move together, with a correlation of 1 meaning stocks move up and down perfectly and a correlation of zero suggesting there is no linear relationship.
The findings indicated that the correlation has moved from 0.25 to almost 0.40 in less than a year and is the highest in 20 years. This means that share prices are moving together quite closely – everything up one day and down the next. We all knew this of course, but now we have the statistical proof!
Why? It could be any of:
- Negative equity market sentiment – when everyone is nervous, they tend to move like a herd
- High volatility – related to nervousness and other trading-based factors
- Macro or thematic trading – if global growth assumptions are adjusted, then all the affected companies (which means virtually everything!) move in the same direction
While there are many suggested reasons behind the increased volatility of markets and the increased correlation of stocks, let’s focus on a couple of the key issues
- Will it last?
- What can an investor do to avoid “market” returns, particularly if you’re not that confident about the market?
The study suggests that the correlation in ASX 200 stocks spikes in periods of market volatility (such as during the GFC and the Asian financial crisis) and falls again when the volatility subsides. So if you suspect, as we do, that volatility is likely to continue, then trying to “pick” stocks might require a different approach. Choosing companies with solid fundamentals becomes a challenge when companies are moving together so closely, with returns dominated by macro themes and the global risk appetite or statements from bureaucrats and politicians.
A less than satisfactory approach is to keep all your assets in cash, as while this may deliver less variation in your investment portfolio balance it is hardly a sensible way to plan for retirement with a potential loss of purchasing power and little in the way of income in a falling interest rate environment.
Another option is to tough it out. Pick those good quality companies to your heart’s content, buy them when they get dragged down with every other average run-of-the-mill enterprise, and when volatility eases, benefit as the true value of your quality investment is appreciated. This is a pretty smart strategy, and one that we try and take advantage of, but the downside is in the timing. This strategy requires a bit of patience for the dust of high volatility and high correlation to settle.
The third option is to try and add something from outside the ASX 200 into your portfolio. Something LESS correlated. These companies are often overlooked by larger managers, hedge funds and high frequency traders, so their valuations are often a better reflection of the basic fundamentals, allowing for the normal pricing anomalies. Smaller companies often have greater flexibility in their operations and can drive above average growth, even when the underlying macroeconomic environment is weak. They can also be quite simple and easy to understand, rather than large conglomerates with layers of complexity. And smaller companies generally deliver higher returns when markets rebound.
While investing in smaller companies is not without risk, the risk profile hasn’t changed much; whereas for larger companies, even quality large companies, it has increased substantially. We think it’s a good idea to think outside the ASX 200 “box”, so to speak, and broaden your investment universe. It may mean your portfolio moves more in line with things you understand and expect.
It’s certainly easier than trying to become the ultimate expert on European politics, Chinese steel production and US fiscal cliffs!