Avoiding poor stocks when investing is as important as selecting big winners.

One or two bad performers is all it takes to damage a portfolio. Investors should always consider preserving capital rather than just focusing on potential returns when choosing stocks.

With any stock, you need to ask: what can go wrong? Where are the risks?

Sometimes today’s returns don’t tell the whole story: there are many cases where stocks with big underlying problems have outperformed for a period; Vocation is a recent example which performed strongly before collapsing and ultimately being delisted from the ASX. Other classic examples include Babcock and Brown, and ABC Learning, which also experienced strong growth before being delisted.

There is no such thing as the perfect stock, but what do investors need to watch out for?

1. You need an MBA to figure out the business model: Good stocks should always be simple and easy to understand. A good test is to see if you can explain it to somebody else. If you can’t explain it, how are you going to evaluate it? Overly complex business structures can hide myriad problems, which won’t be revealed until the company is in trouble.

2. Risk of regulatory change: Government regulation may impact many sectors, such as telecommunications, aged care, healthcare, education, child care, and so on. Anything that requires a high degree of government funding is a high potential risk. Investors need to understand the risk and avoid over-allocating to stocks which may suffer from a sudden legislative or regulatory change.

3. The stock is running too hot: Nothing is more tempting for investors than an already hot stock, but following the herd might be high risk. High performance can mask underlying problems, and may also create other issues, as equity could become cheaper than debt. I once heard a CEO say it is cheaper to raise capital than to borrow. The key is always being mindful of valuation – you need to work out if it is fairly valued, and if the company can keep it going. You need to know your timeframe and understand that surprises come along – look at Brexit and Trump and how certain stocks reacted to that news.

4. Poor management track record: Investors who pay more attention to company management can be rewarded. Just as good management may indicate a good stock, poor management may be a warning sign. Management alone won’t make a stock a buy or a sell, but if a stock already has inherent problems then a poor management track record will only make it less appealing.

5. Risk of structural change: Change and disruption is creating opportunities and crises for many different stocks. Structural change can be hugely influential. To take an overseas example, look what happened to companies like Blockbuster. Consider what online real estate listings have done to newspaper classifieds, and what Uber has done to the taxi industry. You can be a good company, but things can change quickly. It’s important to understand the risks of disruption if possible.

By Leanne Pan, Equity Income (Imputation) Fund Manager – May 2017

Related Content

Prime Value Celebrates 27 Years

16 April 2025

Prime Value celebrates 27 years of growth for investors Boutique multi-award-winning investment house, Prime Value Asset Management, has notched up 27 years of delivering investment returns for investors with the Prime Value Growth Fund, which invests in Australian equities, launched during April 1998. Fast forward to 2025 and the manager now offers a suite of […]

CONTINUE READING

Market ‘in flux’ opening opportunities for active small cap managers

10 April 2025

Active managers are well placed to take advantage of a volatile small cap investing environment, where markets are in a state of flux due to uncertainty about everything from tariffs to interest rates, according to Richard Ivers, Portfolio Manager for the Prime Value Emerging Opportunities Fund. He said volatility in reporting season was elevated, with […]

CONTINUE READING

Novotel Cairns Oasis Resort wins Bronze at the 2024 Qantas Australian Tourism Awards

26 March 2025

The Novotel Cairns Oasis Resort, owned by Prime Value Asset Management and Shakespeare Property Group, has been recognised among Australia’s best accommodation providers at the 2024 Qantas Australian Tourism Awards. The Novotel Cairns Oasis Resort was awarded Bronze in the 4-4.5 Star Deluxe Accommodation category at the awards ceremony, considered tourism’s ‘night of nights’, held […]

CONTINUE READING
FIND OUT HOW TO INVEST WITH US

We'll get back to you within 24 hours.

CHAT WITH US