- Unlike most active funds, Prime Value Asset Management looks for stocks with a lower rate of return, but more certainty
- Small industrials trade at an unusual discount to both large caps and the small resources index
- Prime’s top picks highlight stocks with entrenched market positions and hard-to-replicate businesses
“We companies where we think there’s a far greater certainty of the outcome, as opposed to a far greater upside,” he says.
Among the 35-40 stocks in Prime’s small caps portfolio, the biggest holdings have a lower rate of return.
“That sounds a little counterintuitive, but it gives greater certainty that there’s not going to be a slip-up,” Younger says.
“Generally, stocks that have great certainty are going to be a bit more expensive and that’s why the internal rate of returns are lower.”
These stocks tend to perform “exceptionally well” when markets fall, because they are less volatile.
Lagging returns create opportunities
Younger sees myriad opportunities because the small industrials are lagging large cap returns, having outperformed historically.
Since the onset of the pandemic in January 2020, the small ‘uns have managed 1% per annum, compared with a long-term return of 8%.
The S&P/ASX 200 stocks have returned around 30% since the plague descended.
Younger contends there’s a disconnect between earnings and valuations between the small industrials, and both the large caps and small resources indices.
Prime defines small caps as any industrial stock outside the top 100.
Prime also runs a microcaps fund, for stocks with a $100-500 million market cap.
“If we do have anything valued less than that, it’s probably because we got it wrong and they have fallen to that level,” Younger quips.
The small caps fund’s holdings average $1.7 billion, while the microcaps on average are worth $400 million.
Interest rate headwinds are ‘abating’
Given small caps historically are sensitive to interest rates, the Reserve Bank’s consecutive hikes of 4.25 percentage points up to November 2023 knocked the sector for a Bazball six.
Since then, the rates outlook has become “foggy”, with 0.75pp of hikes this year. The RBA held tight in its last two monthly meetings.
“It’s hard to say, but it looks like the risk to rates is to the downside,” Younger says.
Another reason for the underperformance is that resource stocks – especially gold exposed ones – have been on a tear.
Younger says the rotation from small industrials to small resources has created the biggest divergence between the sectors historically.
Five of the best
Prime’s top five small-cap stocks are Cuscal (ASX:CCL), Dalrymple Bay Infrastructure (ASX:DBI), Pinnacle Investment (ASX:PNI), Regis Healthcare (ASX:REG) and Auckland International Airport (ASX:AIA).
Younger dubs payments infrastructure owner Cuscal a “fascinating business”.
In essence, any electronic payment needs to be processed, cleared and settled.
“Only five companies have access to these payment rails,” Younger says.
These are the Big Four banks – and you guessed it – Cuscal.
Younger says electronic payments have grown at around 7% a year for the last two decades, growth spurred by burgeoning smaller non-cash transactions.
Who pays cash for their lattes these days?
Take or pay, we don’t care which
With Queensland metallurgical coal terminal Dalrymple Bay, Prime sees double-digit growth in distributions over the next five years.
Dalrymple has take-or-pay contracts, meaning the company is paid to handle set volumes. In recent years, actual tonnages have fallen short.
“Miners not using this capacity don’t want to give it up because they want to keep it for when they actually need it,” Younger says.
He says Dalrymple’s port charges are far lower than any facility in the “near vicinity”.
While Pinnacle is a listed rival to Prime, Younger gives credit where it’s due.
“They’ve got an amazing track record of being able to cherry-pick very high-quality managers.”
Pinnacle paid nothing for a 25% stake in an incubated fund, Lifecycle.
Eighteen months later, Lifecycle has grown to $30 billion of funds under management – and is highly profitable.
Retirement and nursing home operator Regis should benefit from regulatory changes that channel more government funding into the sector (as well as demanding better care standards).
There’s only one Auckland Airport
Younger loves oligopolies, “because the competition tends to be a lot more rational in those environments”.
For that reason, the fund is exposed to the smaller New Zealand market that spawns such concentration.
Auckland Airport fits the bill, accounting for the bulk of passenger movements.
The owners have invested heavily in capacity expansion, which should see earnings double over the next five years.
That proves that in the small cap sphere, finding untapped value is not just a flight of fantasy.
This story does not constitute financial product advice. You should consider obtaining independent advice before making any financial decision.
Source: Stockhead