Is the market currently expensive?

This is something we hear a lot from investors, and see a lot in the mainstream papers.

But is it really the correct question to be asking?

It can be easy to forget we do not own the market – rather, we own a portfolio of stocks.

While individual stocks operate within the broader stock market, too much anxiety over whether the market is expensive or not is a bit like owning a property in St Kilda and worrying about national housing values – national values provide little insight into an individual property’s performance.

There are four main reasons we don’t like to become too worried about the market’s valuation:

1) Predicting the macro is risky: We have a philosophy of not trying to predict the macro, because it’s fraught with risk – consider those big macro calls around Brexit and Trump, which surprised everyone last year. It’s highly risky to build investment cases from these predictions.

2) We have a go-anywhere mandate: Being able to invest in “all caps” provides a broader set of opportunities than large or small caps – as we invest far and away from the top 20 stocks, the index is even less relevant.

3) We simply don’t own the market as most people perceive it: A concentrated portfolio invests actively, which means much of the price movement in our portfolio is not explained by the index’s price movement. Our results look substantially different than the market over a given period with our goal to generate positive returns significantly over the long term.

4) Portfolio and index volatility are two different things: We see the market as quite volatile. But we believe our portfolio has potentially less relative risk than the market. This is because we hold a portfolio of companies with greater upside than the market generally – it’s a by-product of sifting through an index to find quality. Remember, every index includes poor performers which you would never consider investing in, because they are likely to fall heavily during any downturn.

By ST Wong, August 2017

Related Content

Dividends surge in popularity, but investors must look beyond yield

24 September 2026

Dividend stocks continue to surge in popularity as franking credits were left untouched in the Federal Budget, but investors must look beyond yield for long-term success, according to a dividends investing expert. Leanne Pan, Portfolio Manager for the Prime Value Equity Income (Imputation) Fund, which debuted in 2001 and has consistently outperformed its benchmark, said […]

CONTINUE READING

Small industrials earnings and valuation gap narrows

10 September 2026

Strong earnings growth and increased deal activity are creating opportunities among quality small industrials, despite an uneven economic recovery. Quality small industrials are seeing their earnings outperform expectations as deal activity picks up, though recovery remains uneven. The gulf between earnings and valuations for quality small industrial stocks could be starting to narrow as corporate […]

CONTINUE READING

Criterion: The fund with the tortoise-over-the-hare approach to small cap stock selection

17 July 2026

Unlike most active funds, Prime Value Asset Management looks for stocks with a lower rate of return, but more certainty Small industrials trade at an unusual discount to both large caps and the small resources index Prime’s top picks highlight stocks with entrenched market positions and hard-to-replicate businesses While most fund managers boast about snaring […]

CONTINUE READING
FIND OUT HOW TO INVEST WITH US

We'll get back to you within 24 hours.

CHAT WITH US