Stocks can switch from triumph to disappointment in myriad ways – CBL recently demonstrated how an irresistible stock may crash and burn, reminding investors about prioritising capital protection over soaring share prices. Yet there was always one key reason why CBL was a riskier stock than first appeared when it was flying high.

CBL is an insurance company which listed in New Zealand during October 2015, soon becoming a market darling.

After opening on New Zealand’s exchange at NZ$1.73 the company’s share price climbed to NZ$3.00 over two years. There aren’t too many investments which nearly double your money in that time frame – investors who bought in at the IPO would have been feeling extremely good about CBL, while others clamoured to ride the price upward. What could go wrong?

Anyone looking solely at price would have experienced a huge shock when CBL went into administration during February 2018. From success story to bust, what went wrong?

This is a pattern which repeats on share markets. In Australia, we saw high flying stocks like Babcock and Brown, and ABC Learning eventually delisted from the exchange, leaving investors with nothing.

The reason for each failure is different, but some of the lessons are the same. Babcock and Brown and ABC Learning reflected over-leveraged investments pre-GFC. The reason for CBL’s collapse is different again. But in all these cases the warning signs for investors were there early on.

Investors will only find the warnings signs when they are committed to minimising risk and protecting capital. There are many indicators to consider, including company management, balance sheet, competition, regulatory risk and more.

Because CBL’s share price was doing extremely well it was worth considering for investment. But share price is only one indicator, and we needed to dig deeper.

CBS displayed good prospects, yet one key aspect didn’t sit too well: CBL was a monoline. In other words, it’s an insurance business with only one line of business – builders insurance.

CBL was writing builders insurance in France and other markets – investors might now wonder how a New Zealand firm could have a competitive advantage in these markets. It’s an interesting question but may not explain everything. We don’t know the full story behind CBL’s problems. But there is an acute lesson on the risks involved investing in a single-product company.

Any monoline business has an extra risk: if the single business line is ever in trouble, there is no place to hide. That’s the story of CBL.

By ST Wong, CIO Prime Value Asset Management – April 2018

Related Content

MoneyTalks: 3 definitely not disco picks with Rich and Mike from their Prime Value Emerging Opportunities Fund

10 August 2022

Today we’re delighted to welcome Richard Ivers and and Mike Younger, running point on the Prime Value Emerging Opportunities Fund at Prime Value Asset Management We got on the blower to Richard after the Prime Value Emerging Opportunities Fund kicked a goal by securing a rating among Australia’s ‘Star Managers’ by the fin services journos at Financial […]

CONTINUE READING

Diversified income strategy more relevant as interest rates play ‘catch up’ on inflation

9 May 2022

The RBA may have raised interest rates, but Matthew Lemke, fund manager (income funds) with boutique investment house Prime Value Asset Management, says cash investors are still in the wilderness, and now paying an even higher price for safety. Mr Lemke says growing inflation has left cash investors so far behind they are unlikely to […]

CONTINUE READING

Navigating a commodity boom without buying miners.

25 March 2022

Richard Ivers is portfolio manager of the Prime Value Emerging Opportunities Fund How have you beat the Small Ords without investing in resources stocks? Not investing in small resource stocks has been a headwind over the last six months. When resources stocks run, they tend to run hard, like we are currently seeing. But we have […]

CONTINUE READING
FIND OUT HOW TO INVEST WITH US

We'll get back to you within 24 hours.

CHAT WITH US